top of page
Search

I ASKED FOR FIRM...

Writer: Tara R
Tara R
9 hours ago
4 min read


Let me start by saying I didn't write it.


I mean, I asked for it, I prompted it, I typed the words "make it firm" into a little box at 11:15 pm on a Tuesday night while lying in bed in a sheet mask, which is not, legally speaking, a coherent state of mind. But I did not write it. I want that on the record. Notarized, if possible.


Here's what happened.


Lisa moved me to Raffle.


For those who don't sit on a spring benefit committee at an Upper East Side school (congratulations, truly), let me explain. There are jobs, and there are jobs. Decor is a job. Decor is centerpieces and a lighting guy named Teo and a venue walkthrough where you get to tilt your head and say things like "what if the room felt more… Tuscan?" Raffle is sitting at a folding table in the lobby selling tickets for a Peloton someone's husband already has two of. (One is in the guest room. The other is where he hangs his blazers.)


Me? I signed up for Decor. In September, mind you. Online which is current day in ink, basically. Then on Monday I opened the committee Google Doc and found my name, in a different font, under Raffle. No email. No text. No "hey, quick thing." Just a font change, which, let's be real, is the Google Doc equivalent of moving someone's place card while they're in the ladies' room.


So I did what any reasonable woman of my age and station does now. I didn't call Lisa. I didn't text Lisa. I didn’t “accidentally” run into Lisa at Ralph's. (I thought about it. I know her coffee order. I know her time.) I opened my AI assistant.


I use it for everything. Recipes. Movie suggestions. Ideas for gifts. Questions I'm too embarrassed to ask my actual doctor. It's helpful, it's tireless and most poignantly, it never says "I'll call you back" or "Mom, I'm busy." It is, frankly, the most supportive relationship in my life, and I say that as someone with a wide and generous community and a husband who nods.


I typed, "Write an email to Lisa about moving me from Decor to Raffle. Firm but nice."


Then, because I am who I am, I added, "Actually, more firm."


Then, "She does this to everyone."


Then, "She did it to Jen last year with the auction catalog."


Then, "Make it so she knows."


Then I adjusted my mask, which had slid.


What did I mean by "so she knows"? I honestly don't know. Knows what? That I'm upset? That I have feelings about centerpieces? That I see her? I think I meant it the way you tell your colorist to go “just a little brighter.” Like, give me blonde vibes; I want to be spiritually blonde, not literally blonde.


The assistant doesn’t do vibes.


The assistant took it as a mandate.


I'm not going to share the whole email. I'll just say it had headers. Headers. It had a section titled "Timeline of Events." It referenced the September sign-up sheet, the Google Doc version history (it found the version history), and -- I genuinely don't know how -- the exact date of the auction catalog incident with Jen. It used the phrase "a pattern of unilateral reassignment." It used the phrase “I want to be clear” more than once. It closed with “I trust this will not happen again,” which I swear to the high heavens I have never once uttered to a soul.


And it signed off "Warmly."


YIkes…Warmly? Let’s just wrap up that ice pick in a nice Cuccinelli throw, shall we?


Did I read it before I hit send? Ummmm. Define "read." I skimmed it. I saw "Hi Lisa," I saw "Warmly," and I saw a lot of competent-looking paragraphs in between, and I thought, that's long, but she'll get the gist. Then I peeled off my sheet mask and went to sleep like a woman with a clean conscience and very hydrated skin.


At 7:52 the next morning, my phone rang.


Lisa.


WTF. Nobody calls someone who doesn’t have a dog before 8am. Nobody. So when I saw "Lisa (Benefit)" on the screen, I thought, for sure someone had died. Then I remembered the email and thought, oh. Someone died, and it's me. Socially.


She was crying.


Not polite crying. Not "I'm just so tired" crying. Real crying with jagged breath. The kind you hear through the wall of a prewar.


"I didn't know you felt this way," she said.


I didn't either! I wanted to say. I felt like a woman who wanted Decor! I didn't know I felt a timeline!


"I moved you because Courtney said you're so great with people," she said. "Raffle is the people job."


Raffle is the people job.


I repeat: Raffle. Is. The people job.


I had been demoted as a compliment.


I said all the right things. I said I was so sorry. I said it had been a long week. I said I'd been "dealing with something," which is technically true if the something is my personality. I did not say "my AI wrote it," because there is simply no version of that sentence that makes you sound better.


When we hung up, I did the only logical thing. I asked the assistant to write an apology.


I know.


"Write Lisa an apology," I typed. "Warm. Humble. SHORT."


It decided humble was the operative word. It wrote four paragraphs. It took full responsibility, acknowledged "the harm caused" and offered to step down from the committee entirely. It suggested a strategy to "make amends to Jen." It used the word reflect three times. I asked for short. I got a novella.


I didn't send it to Lisa. I'm not a monster. I did, however, for reasons I still can't reconstruct, send Jen the paragraph about making amends with Jen. So now Jen is also not speaking to me, and Jen wasn't even involved. Jen is just confused. Jen texted "????" and then nothing, which is somehow worse than crying.


I'm doing Raffle, by the way. I'm a natural. I sold the raffle tickets for the Peloton to the dad who I'm pretty sure now owns three Pelotons.


Apparently I'm great with people.


Just not in writing.


 
 
 

Comments


Recent Posts

Archive

Tags

Follow

Address

New York, NY, USA

©2017 BY ITSALLMATERIAL. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

bottom of page